Animal welfare law, farm subsidies and plant-based labelling in the US
Quick answer
The United States has no general federal law governing how farm animals are raised: the Animal Welfare Act explicitly excludes farm animals used for food, and the Humane Methods of Slaughter Act excludes poultry, which is over 90% of the animals killed. Protection therefore comes from state ballot measures — California's Proposition 12 and Massachusetts's Question 3 are the strongest — and from corporate purchasing commitments. More than a dozen states have passed laws restricting meat-style names on plant-based products, and several have been blocked by courts on First Amendment grounds.
The American picture is a patchwork by design. Federal law regulates transport and slaughter narrowly; everything about the life of the animal is left to states, most of which exempt 'customary agricultural practices' from their cruelty statutes. That is why the biggest recent welfare changes came from voters rather than legislators.
Key facts
- World Animal Protection index (2020)
- D — The 2020 assessment highlights gaps in federal farm animal protection and exemptions for standard industry practices.
- Practices reviewed
- 10
- Outright bans
- 0 of 10
- Region
- North America
What is banned, restricted or legal
- 2Restricted
- 7Partial
- 1No protection
Federal farm animal welfare on farm
No general federal standard
The Animal Welfare Act of 1966 excludes animals raised for food and fibre. There is no federal law on stocking density, cages, mutilations or breeding for the on-farm phase.
Humane slaughter
Covers mammals, excludes poultry
The Humane Methods of Slaughter Act covers livestock, with stunning requirements and a religious-slaughter alternative. Poultry is excluded, although USDA poultry regulations require good commercial practices.
Twenty-Eight Hour Law
1873 transport law, weakly enforced
Animals must be unloaded for food, water and rest every 28 hours of transport. USDA long argued it did not apply to trucks; enforcement actions are rare.
California Proposition 12
since 2022Space standards for veal and pork; cage-free eggs
Voters approved minimum space requirements in 2018 and applied them to products sold in the state regardless of origin. The Supreme Court upheld it in National Pork Producers v. Ross (2023).
Massachusetts Question 3
Confinement and sales standards for eggs, veal and pork
Approved in 2016 and amended in 2021. Egg and veal requirements applied from January 2022; enforcement of whole-pork sales requirements began in August 2023.
Gestation crates
Banned in roughly ten states
Florida, Arizona, Oregon, Colorado, California, Massachusetts, Michigan, Ohio, Rhode Island and Maine have restricted them to varying degrees; most US sows are still confined during part of pregnancy.
Ag-gag laws
Undercover documentation criminalised in several states
Laws penalising recording on farms have been struck down in whole or part in Idaho, Utah, Iowa, Wyoming, Kansas and North Carolina on First Amendment grounds; versions survive in Arkansas, Missouri, Montana and elsewhere.
Foie gras
California ban upheld; New York City ban litigated
California's production and sale ban survived repeated challenges. New York City's 2019 ban has been delayed by state agency action and litigation.
Fur sales
since 2023California banned new fur sales from 2023
Several cities including Los Angeles, San Francisco and Ann Arbor have their own bans.
Cosmetics testing
Banned in ten-plus states
California, Illinois, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, Virginia, Maryland, Hawaii, Louisiana and Maine restrict the sale of newly animal-tested cosmetics. No federal ban exists.
Where the Farm Bill money goes
Federal support includes commodity programmes, subsidised crop and livestock insurance, and disaster payments. Feed production can benefit indirectly. USDA-supervised checkoff programmes promote commodities using mandatory industry assessments; these producer-funded levies are distinct from federal subsidy spending.
Farm Bill total, roughly
Share of US corn used for feed and ethanol
Annual federal crop insurance subsidy
Checkoff programme revenues
The state-by-state fight over 'burger' and 'milk'
States have adopted differing restrictions on plant-based meat and dairy names, with some narrowed or blocked through litigation. FDA’s 2023 draft milk-alternative guidance recommends identifying the plant source and voluntarily comparing nutrients where appropriate. Its January 2025 draft guidance separately addresses other plant-based alternatives. These drafts are non-binding recommendations.
- FDA draft guidance permits 'soy milk' and 'oat milk' with a voluntary nutrition comparison statement
- State meat-labelling laws vary; several are enjoined or narrowed by courts
- USDA regulates labels on products containing meat or poultry, FDA regulates purely plant-based products
- 'Vegan' has no federal legal definition; certification is private (Certified Vegan, Vegan Action)
- Cultivated meat is jointly regulated by FDA and USDA; Florida and Alabama have banned its sale
What is moving next
- 1
EATS Act proposals in Congress that would pre-empt state animal-welfare sales standards such as Proposition 12
- 2
Further state cage-free sales laws taking effect, including Michigan and Rhode Island
- 3
Litigation over state bans on cultivated meat
- 4
Petitions to bring poultry under the Humane Methods of Slaughter Act
Groups working on this
Questions people ask
Are farm animals protected by US federal law?
Barely. The Animal Welfare Act excludes them, the Humane Methods of Slaughter Act covers only mammals at the moment of slaughter, and the 28-Hour Law governs transport. Nothing federal regulates how animals are housed on farms.
What did Proposition 12 do?
It set minimum space requirements for laying hens, breeding pigs and calves whose products are sold in California, no matter where they were raised. The Supreme Court upheld it in 2023, making state sales standards a viable national lever.
Is it illegal to call something a veggie burger in the US?
There is no general federal ban on “veggie burger”. State requirements differ, and litigation has narrowed or blocked some restrictions. Labels must clearly identify the food and must not mislead consumers.
What are ag-gag laws?
State laws criminalising undercover filming or employment at agricultural facilities. Courts have struck down key provisions in at least six states as unconstitutional restrictions on speech.
How much does the US subsidise meat and dairy?
There is no single total for meat and dairy support. Relevant programmes include feed-crop support, livestock insurance subsidies and disaster payments. Commodity checkoff marketing is funded by industry assessments, rather than federal subsidy appropriations.
How to interpret the rules in United States
A welfare rule, a product label and a farm payment answer different questions. Read each practice separately: a restriction on one housing system is not a ban on all confinement, and recognition of sentience does not by itself prohibit farming or slaughter. The source links below are the starting point for checking the legal text.
| Question to check | Why the distinction matters |
|---|---|
| Is this enacted law, a proposal or a voluntary commitment? | A campaign, consultation or retailer pledge does not have the same legal effect as a rule in force. |
| Which territory, species and production stage are covered? | National, state or regional rules may differ. A rule for laying hens may not apply to broilers; a gestation restriction may not cover farrowing. |
| Are there exemptions or a transition period? | An announced ban may start later, allow specified exceptions or apply only to new facilities. |
| Does the rule concern production, sale or imports? | A domestic production ban does not automatically ban importing or selling the same product. |
| What is the denominator and year for a subsidy figure? | A total farm budget, a coupled-payment allocation and an estimate including feed support cannot be compared as if they measured the same thing. |
Before relying on a legal claim
- Open the linked primary source and check its latest consolidated version, territorial scope and commencement provisions.
- Distinguish legal requirements from vegan certification or marketing claims. Vegan and allergen-free are not equivalent assurances.
- Check whether a proposal has since passed, changed or been withdrawn. A review year is not a guarantee that every development has been verified.
- For compliance, complaints or legal advice, consult the responsible authority or a qualified adviser in the jurisdiction concerned.
Primary sources
Other countries
Data: USDA — Humane Methods of Slaughter Act · Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with a link back.
Plain-language summary reviewed in 2026, not legal advice. Law changes — check the primary source before relying on it.